Every summer about 450 kids, from elementary through middle school age, go through the Katharine Hepburn Cultural Arts Center's camps. When they get older, their parents ask whether the programs can continue. Executive director Brett Elliott has said that with the space the Kate has now, offering those programs isn't realistic.
That problem is a fair way to understand what Old Saybrook approved on September 29. The $11.3 million project doesn't add a single seat to the main theater. It's meant to fix the calendar. Right now, a class, a camp and a concert can't all happen in the building at the same time.
The 284-seat theater stays the main auditorium. Centerbrook Architects designed a two-story, 7,500-square-foot addition built around four flexible rooms. When the two second-floor rooms are opened into one, they make a second space for performances and lectures that holds up to 90 people. The Kate's campaign page lists open mic nights, teen summer theater, master classes and workshops among the uses it has in mind.
The plan, by floor:
| Floor | What the plan includes |
|---|---|
| First | Classrooms, expanded museum, renovated kitchen, stage door, elevator to stage level, box office with two windows, volunteer check-in and lockers, administrative and production offices |
| Second | Lobby, classrooms, education office, green room with hospitality and laundry, unisex restroom, makeup and hair stations, enlarged backstage, storage for theater chairs and tables |
Most of the list is support space. The building went up in 1911. In the Kate's own plan, it now serves ten times as many people as it did then, "within a footprint that has barely changed." The Kate opened there in 2009 and now hosts about 400 events a year. Elliott has described the conflicts that come with that load. Some programs get cut back or moved around because they overlap with others. With more rooms, a class could run down the hall while the main theater gets ready for its next show.
The Kate's FAQ says the new spaces should support an audience increase of 30% to 35%. The Kate already offers free student matinees, which reach more than 2,000 local students a year.
More than 1,400 voters took part in the September 29 referendum. Each project was a separate question.
| Question | Total cost | Bonding cap | Yes | No |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DPW garage reconstruction | $6.2 million | $5.2 million | 1,237 | 209 |
| Kate addition and renovation | $11.3 million | $6.3 million | 848 | 604 |
The garage passed with about 86% of the vote. The Kate passed with about 58%. Before the vote, both questions had the same official backing. The Board of Finance voted 7–0 on July 28 to recommend the Kate appropriation and bond authorization. On August 11 the Board of Selectmen voted unanimously to call the special town meeting and referendum.
The gap came from how the Kate is set up. It's a 501(c)(3) nonprofit that isn't part of town government, but it operates in a building the town owns. Some residents asked why town money should go to the Kate's project instead of other town priorities. In a September 18 letter to the editor published by Zip06, Eleanor Susan LaPlace called the Kate a "want" rather than a town need. She worried that taxpayers could end up covering the nonprofit's $5 million share if grants or pledges came up short.
First Selectman Carl Fortuna answered with the deed to the building:
"The Kate is a 501c3 that operates in the building, but the building is a town building and at the end of the day, in addition to the benefit that the expansion will bring for The Kate and the town, we are investing in a town building."
Resident Bill Peace made a similar case on referendum day. He called the Kate a community asset, as WTNH reported, and pointed out that the town owns the building. On taxes, the Kate's FAQ says Fortuna has indicated the effect should be minimal. Its reasons are that the town's debt service drops significantly over the next five and ten years, and that money added to the town's long-term liability fund supports level-to-declining debt service even with this bond and the DPW bond.
Most of the confusion about the money comes from figures that cover different things. Here they are separately:
Pledges can be paid over time through December 31, 2030. The naming list shows which parts of the plan donors have already backed. The existing theater, at $500,000 and up, is marked reserved, along with the first-floor lobby of the new wing, the Hepburn Legacy Entryway and both box office windows. The new wing itself, at $1.5 million and up, is still available. So are the museum collections storage vault and the new museum exhibit cases.
The Kate's other argument was about Main Street. Its FAQ cites research showing patrons spend about $34 at nearby restaurants, shops and businesses per visit, which adds up to roughly $3 million a year in local spending. The Kate's analysis projects that figure could reach $4 million with the added programming. The FAQ also says ticket sales and program enrollment already cover 67% of the Kate's annual operating budget.
The next step is paperwork. The town has to secure the bonds first. After that, the Kate will issue a request for proposals for construction and set up a committee to review bids. The town expects work to start by the end of 2026 or in early 2027 and to last about a year. The Kate will stay open during construction. Before the vote, officials said the main theater wouldn't be affected even during construction, and that minor disruptions would be announced well in advance.
The Kate says any street or traffic changes around the building will be temporary and coordinated with the town. On parking, it points to existing and planned shared arrangements with nearby businesses, churches and other organizations. The DPW garage is on its own timeline. That project should start in 2027, after a contractor is chosen.
The fall season continues at 300 Main Street, and the current calendar is the kind of busy schedule the expansion is meant to handle. Listings as of early October:
Karla Bonoff, singer-songwriter. Tuesday, October 6, 7:30 p.m. Limited availability.
Stand Up and Speak OUT!, a musical about ending bullying. Wednesday, October 7, 7 p.m.
The Band Band, a tribute to The Band. Friday, October 9, 8 p.m.
Lucio Fontana, FRAMES in FILM series. Saturday, October 10, 1 p.m.
Eileen Ivers, fiddler. Saturday, October 10, 8 p.m.
Rusalka, Salt Marsh Opera. Friday, October 16, 7 p.m., and Sunday, October 18, 3 p.m.
Ballet Spooktacular, Eastern CT Ballet. October 24 and 25, three performances each day.
The Zambonis & Big Fat Combo, Sunday, November 1, 7:30 p.m., and Total Mass Retain, Sunday, November 8, 7 p.m.
October 10 is a good example. A 1 p.m. film and an 8 p.m. concert share the same 284 seats. Elliott described the Kate as a building that runs year-round, which gives Main Street businesses steady traffic. After the addition opens, a day like that could also include a class in one of the new rooms.
I'm Nick Prevost, and I serve on Old Saybrook's Planning and Economic Development commissions. If you have questions about how the Kate project or the DPW garage will move forward from here, or how either could affect your part of town, I'm glad to talk them through. Nick Prevost is always happy to hear from neighbors. Let's Connect.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Whether you're buying your first home, searching for a second home along the Connecticut Shoreline, preparing to sell, or exploring your investment options, you deserve an advisor who listens first and understands the market. Nick combines local knowledge, project-management experience, and a practical approach to help you navigate each step with confidence—from the initial conversation through closing and beyond.